South India Against Delimitation

What is Delimitation?

  • Delimitation refers to the redrawing of Lok Sabha and State Assembly constituency boundaries to ensure equal representation based on population.
  • It ensures that each vote carries equal weight and that each elected representative represents a similar number of people.

History of Delimitation in India

  • First Delimitation Commission: 1952
  • Second Delimitation Commission: 1962
  • Third Delimitation Commission: 1973 (based on 1971 Census , completed in 1975 ).
  • Fourth Delimitation Commission: 2002 (based on 2001 Census ).
  • The next delimitation was scheduled after the 2021 Census but has been postponed to after 2026 Census due to the pandemic.

Concerns of Southern States

  • Southern States (Tamil Nadu, Kerala, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, Telangana) have lower population growth rates due to successful population control policies .
  • Between 1971-2011:
    • Northern States’ population share (Bihar, UP, MP, Rajasthan, etc.) rose from 44% to 48.2% .
    • Southern States’ share declined from 24.9% to 21.1% .
  • If delimitation is based on population , Southern States may lose Lok Sabha seats , affecting their representation in Parliament .

Impact of Differential Population Growth on Representation

  • Example from the 2024 General Elections:
    • Malkajgiri (Telangana) has 3.7 million electors , while Lakshadweep has only 57,000 electors .
    • Idukki (Kerala) has 1.2 million electors , while Bangalore North (Karnataka) has 3.2 million electors .
    • This imbalance affects representation and voting power .
 South India Against Delimitation

Global Practices & Alternative Solutions

  • Canada’s Model: Uses correction mechanisms to ensure smaller provinces do not lose representation .
  • Alternative Approach:
    • Consider factors like voter turnout, migration trends, and population density in determining constituencies.
    • Use fertility rate-adjusted population to decide seat distribution.
    • Example: Tamil Nadu’s fertility rate = 1.67 , while some northern states still have 2.3+ .
    • Applying a national average fertility rate can balance representation without penalizing Southern States for effective population control.